Index
Index
IPO Analysis · Part 7 of 13
Priya, a fictional investor, has ₹1.5 lakh ready for an IPO that every WhatsApp group calls a sure thing. The GMP is green and the price band is out. What she has not done is open the Red Herring Prospectus (RHP), the 400-page document where the company must disclose what the marketing leaves out.
A red flag is not a verdict. It is a question the company must answer before you hand over your money. This guide lists ten of them, shows where each sits in the RHP, and ends with a way to score any IPO in about twenty minutes.
Practical Tips
The 10 Red Flags at a Glance
| Red flag | What to check | Where in the RHP |
|---|---|---|
| Mostly OFS | Fresh issue vs OFS split, and who is selling | Offer structure |
| Weak use of proceeds | Large share for debt repayment or "general corporate purposes" | Objects of the Issue |
| Cheap pre-IPO allotments | Shares issued to insiders far below the IPO price in recent months | Capital structure |
| Profit without cash | Operating cash flow negative or far below profit; swelling receivables | Restated financials |
| Heavy related-party deals | Large sales, loans or purchases with promoter-linked entities | Related party note |
| Concentration | One customer or supplier above roughly a third of revenue (a common rule of thumb) | Business, Risk Factors |
| Premium valuation | P/E or P/S well above listed peers with no better growth or returns | Basis for Issue Price |
| Auditor trouble | Auditor change, qualified opinion, restated numbers | Auditor's report |
| Serious litigation | Criminal, regulatory or tax cases against promoters or directors | Outstanding Litigation |
| Pledged or thin promoter stake | Pledged shares, or a promoter stake falling steeply after the issue | Shareholding pattern |
What the Ten Flags Are Really Testing
Flags 1 to 3 ask where your money goes. An OFS pays existing shareholders, not the business. Paytm's ₹18,300 crore IPO had ₹10,000 crore of OFS and ₹8,300 crore of fresh issue. A big slice of proceeds for "general corporate purposes", or cheap shares handed to insiders just before the IPO, suggests the price is not the same for everyone.
Flags 4 to 6 test the quality of earnings. Profit that never becomes operating cash flow, sales to the promoter's own entities, or dependence on one customer can all look fine in a headline P/E and still fail on one bad quarter.
Flags 7 to 10 test credibility: a price above peers, unsettled auditors, serious cases against the promoters, and promoters who have pledged shares or are cutting their stake.
Back to Priya. In ten minutes with the RHP, she finds that about 70% of her IPO's size is OFS and that operating cash flow has been negative for two years while reported profit rose. That is two flags, and she has not reached valuation yet. (Priya's IPO is illustrative.)
Two Real IPOs, Two Different Lessons
| Detail | Paytm (Nov 2021) | Ola Electric (Aug 2024) |
|---|---|---|
| Issue size | ₹18,300 crore | ₹6,145.56 crore |
| Fresh issue / OFS | ₹8,300 crore / ₹10,000 crore | ₹5,500 crore / ₹645.56 crore |
| Flags visible | OFS-heavy, loss-making, valuation concerns | Loss-making (FY23 net loss ₹1,472 crore), ₹800 crore of proceeds for debt repayment |
| Subscription | 1.89x | 4.45x |
| Grey market before listing | Discount of about ₹10–20 | Discount of about ₹3 |
| Listing day | Listed at ₹1,950 on NSE (-9.3%), closed about 27% below the ₹2,150 issue price | Listed flat at ₹76, closed at ₹91.2 |
Paytm shows what flags can cost. Ola Electric shows that flags do not guarantee a fall: it listed flat, rallied on day one and was still loss-making. A good first day proved nothing about the business. Judge flags by the risk they add, not by the listing you hope for.
Practical Tips
Myth: A Positive GMP Means a Clean IPO
Myth: If the grey market is paying a premium, the issue must be sound.
Reality: GMP measures demand, not disclosure quality. Ola's GMP was a small discount just before listing, yet the stock closed about 20% higher. Paytm's grey market discount looked mild next to the ₹586 fall below issue price by the close. Neither number said anything about OFS size or cash flow. Use IPO360's Live GMP Tracker (ipo360.in/gmp) to gauge demand, never to clear an issue.
The GMP tells you what the market feels. The RHP tells you what the company must admit.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
Treat a red flag as a question the company must answer, not as a verdict. Check where the money goes first: OFS share, use of proceeds and pre-IPO allotments. Then test earnings quality, since profit without operating cash flow is the most common trap. Check credibility last: valuation against peers, auditors, litigation and promoter pledges. Remember that Paytm and Ola Electric show flags raise risk without fixing the listing outcome, and that GMP cannot clear an issue. Before your next application, open the RHP, count the flags, and apply only when you can explain each one.