Index
Index
IPO Analysis · Part 3 of 13
Priya has ₹1.5 lakh set aside for an IPO that everyone at her office is discussing. The grey market premium looks strong, subscription is climbing, and the ₹200 price band seems modest. What she cannot answer is the one question that matters before bidding: is ₹200 a fair price for this business, or just a price someone has set with confidence?
That question can be reasoned out in about fifteen minutes, using numbers the company is legally required to publish. This guide covers four valuation checks, shows Priya applying them, and points to where the RHP hides the evidence. Priya and "Kavach Foods Ltd" are illustrative, and the figures are invented to demonstrate the method.
Practical Tips
The four checks that matter
No single ratio proves an IPO is cheap. Each check answers a different question, and each fails in a predictable situation. The table shows which tool suits which company.
| Check | Question it answers | Works best for | Breaks down when |
|---|---|---|---|
| P/E (post-issue) | How many years of profit am I paying for? | Profitable, stable companies | Profits are tiny, lumpy or negative |
| Price to book (P/B) | What do I pay per rupee of net assets? | Banks, NBFCs, housing finance | Asset-light businesses |
| Peer multiple | Is the price in line with listed comparables? | Sectors with clear peers | No true peer exists |
| WACA | Did insiders recently pay far less? | Any IPO | Deals were small or old |
Use at least two. A company that looks fair on P/E but expensive against peers deserves a second look.
Priya runs the numbers on Kavach Foods
Kavach's upper price band is ₹200. Priya starts with the headline P/E, then corrects it for the shares the IPO will create.
| Item | Figure |
|---|---|
| Profit after tax (FY26) | ₹80 crore |
| Shares before issue | 10 crore |
| Fresh issue | 2 crore shares (₹400 crore raised) |
| Pre-issue EPS / P/E | ₹8.00 / 25x |
| Post-issue EPS / P/E | ₹6.67 / 30x |
| Listed peers (P/E) | 22x, 28x, 34x (median 28x) |
| Peer-implied price (post-issue) | ₹187 |
| Pre-IPO round, six months ago | ₹120 (issue price is 1.67x) |
The prospectus headline of 25x looks cheaper than the 28x peer median. On post-issue earnings, though, Kavach is at 30x. Post-issue EPS is a conservative measure, because the ₹400 crore raised may lift profits in later years. It still shows what you pay for the profit that exists today.
Practical Tips
Where the RHP shows its working
Every book-built IPO must explain its price in the "Basis for Issue Price" section of the RHP. Since SEBI's November 2022 amendment, this section must disclose key performance indicators and compare them with listed peers. It must also disclose the weighted average cost of acquisition (WACA) from primary and secondary transactions in the 18 months before filing, with the floor and cap price shown as multiples of that WACA. A committee of independent directors must additionally recommend that the price band is justified.
For Priya, WACA is the quickest red flag. Insiders who paid ₹120 six months ago are now selling or issuing at ₹200, and the RHP should explain what changed in those six months.
Myth: a lower P/E than peers means a bargain
Two IPOs from the Knowledge Base show why valuation and listing day are different things.
| IPO | Issue price | Listing price | Valuation note |
|---|---|---|---|
| Hyundai Motor India (Oct 2024) | ₹1,960 | ₹1,934 (about 1.3% below) | Priced at 26x FY24 earnings vs 29x for Maruti |
| Bajaj Housing Finance (Sep 2024) | ₹70 | ₹150 (+114.3%) | One analyst called it stretched at close to 10x book after the rally |
Hyundai's multiple was below Maruti's, yet retail investors stayed away, filling only about half of their quota. The concern was a narrow gap to the market leader at a time of slowing car sales. Bajaj Housing did the opposite, with demand of over 60x pushing it far past any fair-value estimate.
Valuation tells you what you pay for the risk. It does not tell you what the market will do on listing day.
What Priya decides
At ₹200, Kavach is about 7% above her peer-implied ₹187 and 1.67x its latest pre-IPO price. That is not alarming, but it leaves little room for error, and the premium is justified only if Kavach grows faster than its peers. She halves her bid and keeps the rest for an IPO priced closer to value.
Before your next IPO, do three things. Open the "Basis for Issue Price" section. Recalculate P/E on post-issue shares. Compare the result with at least three listed peers. Loss-making companies need different tools, such as price to sales and unit economics, which is why Paytm (Nov 2021) listed 27% below issue despite its scale.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
A fair IPO price is judged against peers, earnings and recent deals, never in isolation. Recalculate P/E on post-issue shares, since the headline figure usually flatters the issue. Use P/B for lenders and P/E for steady profit-makers, and use at least two checks together. WACA exposes how much insiders recently paid compared with you. The independent directors' price justification is the issuer's argument, not a verdict. A cheaper-than-peers P/E did not save Hyundai India on listing day, so size your bid to your conviction.