Index
Index
IPO Analysis · Part 12 of 13
Priya never applies for an IPO until she has seen one page of the RHP: the table titled "Comparison with listed industry peers." The GMP looks healthy and the subscription chatter is loud. She sees the issue at a lower P/E than its rivals and feels reassured. (Priya is a fictional investor, used here to illustrate the method.) Her mistake is not reading the table. It is trusting it without asking who chose the names in it.
Practical Tips
RoNW stands for Return on Net Worth. It shows how much profit a company earns on the shareholders’ money invested in it.
Formula: RoNW = (Restated profit after tax ÷ Net worth) × 1
Where the peer table comes from
Every offer document must justify its price. Under the SEBI ICDR Regulations, the "Basis for Issue Price" chapter has to compare accounting ratios such as EPS, P/E, RoNW and NAV with companies of comparable size in the same industry. Since the November 2022 amendment, issuers must also compare their KPIs with listed peers that have a similar business model. Industry standards agreed with SEBI also expect an explanation when an issuer picks fewer than three peers.
The regulations set the format, not the list. The issuer and its merchant bankers choose the peers. A peer table shows who the issuer chose to compare itself with, not who the market will compare it with.
A worked example: Hyundai Motor India
Hyundai's RHP (price band ₹1,865–1,960, FY24 figures) named three listed peers. At the top of the band, the issue was priced at 26.28x earnings.
| Company | EPS (₹) | P/E (x) | RoNW | Total income (₹ crore) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hyundai Motor India (issue) | 74.58 | 26.28 | 56.82% | 69,829 |
| Maruti Suzuki India | 429.01 | 29.38 | 15.75% | 141,858 |
| Tata Motors | 81.96 | 11.36 | 36.98% | 437,928 |
| Mahindra & Mahindra | 101.14 | 29.96 | 17.02% | 138,279 |
Source: Hyundai Motor India RHP, as compiled in public IPO notes.
Ignore the per-share columns when comparing across companies. Face values differ (₹10 for Hyundai, ₹5 for Maruti and M&M, ₹2 for Tata Motors), so EPS and NAV per share are not like-for-like. P/E, RoNW and total income are the usable columns.
Four checks before you trust the table
Business fit. Ask whether each peer earns money the way the issuer does. A peer with a large overseas arm, a different product mix or a cyclical profit base can pull the average far from the issuer's own reality.
Size and year. Compare total income, and confirm the peer figures are for the same financial year as the issuer's. Mismatched years quietly change the P/E.
Recompute the average. Never accept the average as printed. Rebuild it, then rebuild it again with one name removed.
Read RoNW beside P/E. A premium P/E is easier to defend when returns on net worth are higher. A very high RoNW can also sit on a thin net worth base, so check what is driving it.
Here is what happens to Hyundai when the peer set changes:
| Peer set | Average P/E | Hyundai (26.28x) vs average |
|---|---|---|
| All three peers | 23.57x | about 11.5% higher |
| Maruti and M&M only | 29.67x | about 11.4% lower |
| Median of three | 29.38x | about 10.6% lower |
Priya rebuilds this table in a spreadsheet and stares at it. The same RHP now says the issue is both pricier and cheaper than its peers.
Practical Tips
Myth vs reality
Myth: a lower P/E than peers means the IPO is cheap.
Reality: a low multiple can mean the market doubts how durable the earnings are. Tata Motors' 11.36x reflects a very different business mix from a pure domestic carmaker. Comparing against it tells you less than the table implies.
The opposite myth is equally common: that a premium P/E must be justified by strong returns. Hyundai's 56.82% RoNW looks far above Maruti's 15.75% and M&M's 17.02%. It still needs checking against how large the net worth base is, and whether that level of return can last.
A peer table also says nothing about listing day. Hyundai's valuation looked broadly in line with peers, yet it listed below its issue price.
When peer comparison breaks down
Peer tables work best for large, profitable, listed-peer-rich sectors like autos or banking. They struggle in four situations. Loss-making companies have no meaningful P/E, so issuers fall back on price-to-sales or other measures, which are easier to flatter. Conglomerates and multi-segment businesses have no clean peer. SME IPOs often have few or no genuine listed comparables, so an issuer may pick bigger, unrelated companies. And a table with only one or two peers should make you ask why more were not available.
Priya's final note on her practice case reads: "Fairly priced if Tata Motors counts as a peer, a modest discount if it doesn't. Not a bargain either way." She does not treat that as a recommendation. She treats it as a reason to read the risk factors before deciding.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
The peer table sits in the "Basis for Issue Price" chapter, and the issuer and its bankers choose who goes in it. Per-share figures like EPS and NAV are not comparable across different face values, so lean on P/E, RoNW and total income. Always recompute the average yourself, because one peer can flip the verdict, as Tata Motors did for Hyundai. A low P/E against peers is not automatically cheap, and a high one is not automatically expensive. Peer comparison is weakest for loss-making firms, conglomerates and SME IPOs. Your next step: before the next IPO closes, copy the peer P/Es into a spreadsheet and rerun the average with and without the outlier.